← All resources
Checklist 4 min read

Switching from your web agency without losing patients

What to collect before you give notice, what can break on switch day, and how to keep your Google rankings when you move your practice website.

By Dr. Meredith Walton, OD · Published October 25, 2026

Most practices stay with a web vendor long after they stop being happy, because switching feels risky. It does not have to be. Nearly everything that goes wrong in a website move comes from a short list of things nobody checked beforehand. This is that list.

1. Signs it's time to switch

  • A simple change, like new hours or a new doctor's bio, takes a ticket and a week.
  • You are not sure what your monthly fee actually pays for.
  • Your site is slow on a phone, or looks like it was built years ago.
  • You never get a report, so you cannot tell whether the site brings in patients.

If two or more of those sound familiar, the risk of staying is quietly larger than the risk of moving.

2. Before you give notice, find out what you own

The single most important step happens while your current vendor is still friendly. Make sure you, not the vendor, hold the keys to each of these:

  • Your domain. The login for the registrar where yourpractice.com is registered. If the vendor registered it in their own account, ask them to transfer it to yours now.
  • Your Google Business Profile. You should be an owner, not just a manager. Agencies are often the primary owner of profiles they set up.
  • Google Analytics and Search Console. Admin access, so your history comes with you.
  • Your content. Doctor bios, service pages and the photos you paid for. Save copies.
  • Connected tools. Online booking, patient forms, contact lens reorders and your optical shop. Note which ones the vendor set up and which accounts they live in.

Collect every login in one place before anything else happens. Recovering a domain or a Google profile from an uncooperative vendor can take weeks.

3. Read your contract

Look for three things: the notice period, who owns the website files and design, and any cancellation fee. Some agencies license the site to you rather than selling it, which means the design stays with them when you leave. That is fine, as long as you know it going in. If anything in the contract is unclear, ask your attorney rather than guessing.

4. What can break on switch day

The website itself is the easy part. The things that break are the invisible connections around it:

  • Email. Your domain's DNS records also route your practice email. Copy every existing record before changing anything, or email can stop arriving.
  • Leftover settings from the old host. Old vendors sometimes leave records or services pointing at your domain. Audit the DNS before you promise a go-live date, not after.
  • Old page addresses. If yourpractice.com/eye-exams becomes yourpractice.com/services/exams, every link and search result to the old address breaks unless it redirects.
  • Tracking phone numbers. Many agencies swap in call-tracking numbers. When you leave, those numbers can stop working while they still sit in directories across the web.

5. Protect your Google rankings

A move done carelessly can cost you rankings you spent years earning. Done right, it usually costs nothing and often helps, because a faster site ranks better.

  • Keep important page addresses, or redirect each old address to its new home.
  • Keep your practice name, address and phone number exactly the same everywhere.
  • Confirm you own the Google profile before the switch, not after.
  • Carry over your page titles, descriptions and structured data, then improve them.

Our local SEO guide covers the fundamentals that should survive any move.

6. The first 30 days after

  • Search your top terms in an incognito window each week and note where you rank.
  • Book a test appointment and submit each form yourself.
  • Send an email to the practice address from outside, to confirm mail still arrives.
  • Check Search Console for pages Google cannot find, and redirect them.
  • Remove the old vendor's access to your domain, Google profile and analytics.

Or let someone else run the checklist

Switching is a project you do once every few years, which is why it feels risky. For us it is part of every new practice. ODpal Local handles the move for you: we collect what you own, audit the DNS, set up redirects and get your new site live in about a week. Your domain stays yours, now and if you ever leave. Book a demo and we will look at your current setup together.

See what ODpal can do for your practice.

A 30 minute walkthrough with someone who knows optometry, using your practice as the example.